Is it worth grading a card?

For most cards, no. Grading pays only when the graded price beats the raw price by more than the fee and the shipping, at the grade the card really gets.

Updated November 17, 2026

For most cards the answer is no. Grading pays only when the graded card sells for more than the raw card would have, by more than the fee and the shipping, and only at the grade the card really gets. This page shows the sum with PSA’s fees as PSA published them on November 16, 2026, so that you can do it for your own card before you spend anything.

The grading-cost calculator does the same sum with the values you type.

The sum

what the graded card sells for minus the grading fee minus shipping minus what the raw card sells for today = what grading leaves you

The last line is the one people forget. You already own a card you could sell raw. Grading only pays for the difference.

What PSA charges

PSA is one of the large grading companies, and the one whose prices this page uses. Its public prices per card, read on November 16, 2026 from PSA’s trading card grading page:

Level Fee Card worth up to Estimated wait
Value $39.99 $500 90 to 100 business days
Standard $59.99 $1,000 70 to 80 business days
Priority $79.99 $1,500 50 to 60 business days
Express $199.00 $2,500 20 to 30 business days

The fee is per card. PSA says the waits are estimates and not promises, and that it may change prices and times. Higher levels exist for cards worth more.

Shipping comes on top, both ways. PSA’s return shipping and insurance within the United States depends on the number of items and on the Max Insured Value. In the first column of PSA’s chart, headed Max Insured Value $2,000, it is $19.99 for one to four items, $24.99 for five to nine and $29.99 for ten to nineteen. The next column, $12,500, reads $34.99, $39.99 and $44.99, and the columns go on up from there (PSA’s postage page, read November 17, 2026; the page says it was last updated on August 29, 2025). The chart does not say whether that value is counted for each item or for the whole order: its footnote speaks of “Packages over $200,000”, and PSA’s FAQ says the rate is determined by “overall card count and declared value”. Send ten cards together and, in the first column, the return shipping is about $3.00 a card instead of $19.99. What you pay to post the cards to PSA is yours to add.

The fee depends on what the card is worth graded

The “worth up to” column is what PSA calls the Max Insured Value. PSA’s FAQ says the service level is determined by it, and that it is your own estimate of what the card is worth after grading, not before.

So a card you expect to be worth $700 as a 10 does not fit the $39.99 level. And if you send a card on the $39.99 level and it comes back worth more than $500, PSA says it moves that card to the level that fits and tells you the additional fee. A good result can cost more than you planned.

Three examples

The card values in these examples are invented to show the arithmetic. They are not prices of any real card. The fees are PSA’s, and the shipping is the $19.99 of the chart’s first column (Max Insured Value $2,000), which each of these cards fits.

A card worth $20 raw, $90 as a PSA 10 and $35 as a PSA 9. It fits the Value level.

Sent on its own, this card earns ten dollars if it gets the top grade and loses forty-five if it gets the next one down. It has to sell for $79.98 graded just to break even.

A card worth $150 raw, $700 as a PSA 10 and $260 as a PSA 9. A 10 would be worth more than $500, so the fee for a 10 is the Standard level’s $59.99.

Here grading pays at either grade, a little as a 9 and a lot as a 10. This is the kind of card grading is for: the gap between raw and graded is several times the fee.

A card worth $2 raw and $25 as a PSA 10.

Even a perfect grade loses money. Most cards are this card.

The grade is the part nobody knows

Every line above depends on the grade, and nobody can tell you the grade before the card is graded. A grader looks at the corners, the edges, the surface and the centering, and PSA’s standards leave room for judgment.

Two things help you be realistic.

First, do the sum for a 9 as well as for a 10. If the card only pays as a 10, you are betting the fee on the top grade.

Second, check what you can check. Centering is the one criterion you can measure at home. PSA’s grading standards, read on November 16, 2026, ask a 10 to be centered within approximately 55/45 on the front and 75/25 on the back, and a 9 within approximately 60/40 on the front and 90/10 on the back. The centering check on this site measures your card against those figures. It measures centering only. A card that is well centered can still have a soft corner or a scratch, so a good centering result is not a grade. A card that is clearly outside the tolerance for a 10 is one where you should use the 9 line of the sum.

Published counts of how many copies of a card got a 10 are worth a look, but they flatter the odds: people send the copies they believe in, not an average copy from a pack.

What this sum leaves out

Sources

Every figure on this page that is not marked as invented comes from PSA’s own pages, read on November 16, 2026:

PSA can change any of these. If a figure here is out of date, the data page says how to tell us.

More: Centering check · Grading cost calculator · All guides